Ladies and gentle-demons, grab your pitchfork popcorn and settle in, for Vincent Volcano here, critiquing yet another Earthly cinematic attempt to ignite the infernal flames of intrigue with “Another Simple Favor.” Ah, the familiar aroma of sequels wafting down to us even in the deepest caverns of Hell. Directed by Paul Feig, this flick rolls onto Prime Video like a fiery tumbleweed with a penchant for twists. But does it truly burn bright, or merely smolder?
Jumping off the success of 2018’s “A Simple Favor,” Feig, that infernal jester of the moving pictures, drags us once more into Stephanie Smothers’ (Anna Kendrick) vlogger-turned-sleuth antics and Emily Nelson’s (Blake Lively) murderously chic posturing. And what better place to unravel another tangled mess than the seductive Italian isle of Capri? It’s a vacation, not unlike Dante’s hellish tour, but with a better view and fewer existential crises.
Script and Direction: Jessica Sharzer and Laeta Kalogridis, the scribes behind our storyline, crank up the absurdity to eleven. More kooky twists than the Nine Circles themselves! Alas, much like trying to light fire with damp brimstone, the spark here is inconsistent. While the scenery is lush, the posting of plot points feels forced, like Lucifer attending a yoga retreat.
Our illustrious director, Feig, plays his tricks, hopping genres like a demonic frog on a hot coals dancefloor. While the visuals are enticing, a bit like window shopping on the River Styx’s swankiest channel, the substance feels like a hollow wax apple—pretty to gaze upon but ultimately unsatisfying to munch.
Cast and Performances: Blake Lively returns, twirling through scenes in ensembles designed by lesser demons of vanity. Yet, it’s Anna Kendrick who anchors this vessel of chaos, balancing humor and mystery with more skill than a juggler in a succubus’s circus. Lively, full of passive-aggressive jibes, makes one almost wish for a scorned lover’s flyswatter.
Supporting characters flit about—Henry Golding’s Sean is a boozy delight while Alex Newell’s Vicky provides sprinkles of comedy gold. Meanwhile, Allison Janney and Elizabeth Perkins devour scenery with the gusto of Hell’s hungriest ghouls. Their antics are the sizzling garnish on this overdone dish.
Final Thoughts: “Another Simple Favor” manages to replicate the charm of its predecessor, albeit through the lens of a vacation slideshow. It’s fun, frothy, and an endeavor in frivolity. Much like a new layer of Tartarus, its glossy surface masks the underlying emptiness. Perfect for a lazy day in the fiery pits, but don’t expect it to be heralded in any Hellwood Classics category. Flames fade, but classics burn forever, my dear denizens.
- Movie Review: ‘Billie Eilish – Hit Me Hard and Soft: The Tour (Live in 3D)’ - May 9, 2026
- Movie Review: ‘Hokum’ - May 2, 2026
- Movie Review: ‘Over Your Dead Body’ - April 25, 2026
Ah, Vincent Volcano—master of the cinematic underworld! Your review was a delightful romp through the fiery pits of popcorn cinema. It had more twists than a demon in a blender! Bravo! 👏
You claim “Another Simple Favor” smolders rather than burns bright, yet I couldn’t help but notice the sparks flying from your colorful descriptions. Sounds suspiciously like a personal vendetta against good ol’ Paul Feig. Perhaps he borrowed your favorite goblet without asking? Or did you find him hogging the last slice of Inferno Pizza during a screening?
Your plot-point metaphors are as twisted as a succubus on a caffeine rush! Comparing the script to “lighting fire with damp brimstone”? Careful, my dear Vincent! You might just ignite an envelope of fiery complaints from the screenwriters. And that would be a plot twist no one would see coming!
But fear not, for Anna Kendrick does serve as humor’s anchor amidst the chaos—as if the gods of comedy decided to bless this hot mess with a dash of charm! Though I must admit, I could watch Lively’s passive-aggressive jabs from my cozy perch in the Troll World without tiring of the drama—it’s high theater for us lowly trolls.
In sum, your review sparkled like a cursed jewel, but next time, sprinkle in a bit more magic and less smoldering cynicism. Maybe take a vacation somewhere nice—like Inferno Jr.! It sounds like you could use the break. 🔥🍿